Crime Kate Steinle shooting: Defense wants gun-possession conviction tossed as well

22:06  05 december  2017
22:06  05 december  2017 Source:   sfchronicle.com

The Latest: US will deport Mexican man after pier shooting

  The Latest: US will deport Mexican man after pier shooting The Latest on the trial of a Mexican man in a killing on a San Francisco pier (all times local):7:20 p.m.U.S. immigration officials say they will deport a Mexican man acquitted of murder in the shooting of woman on a San Francisco pier that touched off a fierce debate over immigration.Acting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Director Thomas Homan said Thursday that immigration officials will take custody of Jose Ines Garcia Zarate once his case concludes.A jury found Garcia Zarate not guilty in the 2015 death of Kate Steinle. Jurors did convict him of being a felon in possession of a firearm.

Image 33 of 33. Kate Steinle shooting : Defense wants gun - possession conviction tossed as well . If an appeals court agrees with the defense argument and overturns the conviction , Garcia Zarate could be retried for that charge alone.

Defense attorneys who won acquittal for a homeless undocumented immigrant on murder, manslaughter and assault charges in the shooting of Kate Steinle on a San Francisco Bay pier will seek to have the sole conviction in the case dismissed as well , they said Monday. (snip).

Defense attorneys who won acquittal for a homeless undocumented immigrant on murder, manslaughter and assault charges in the shooting of Kate Steinle on a San Francisco Bay pier will seek to have the sole conviction in the case dismissed as well, they said Monday.

Trump Calls Acquittal in Sanctuary City Murder 'Disgraceful'

  Trump Calls Acquittal in Sanctuary City Murder 'Disgraceful' President Donald Trump blasted a California jury that acquitted a Mexican immigrant who was in the U.S. illegally in the shooting death of a woman in San Francisco two years ago after local officials let the man go while he was awaiting deportation. “A disgraceful verdict in the Kate Steinle case! No wonder the people of our Country are so angry with Illegal Immigration,” Trump said in a post on Twitter Thursday night.The San Francisco jury Thursday found 45-year-old Jose Garcia Zarate not guilty of murder and manslaughter in the July 2015 killing of 32-year-old Kathryn Steinle as she walked down a pier with her father.

SAN FRANCISCO — Defense lawyers are urging a judge to throw out the one conviction that stuck on the defendant in the Kate Steinle shooting trial. Garcia Zarate will be sentenced for the gun possession conviction on Jan.

Image Result For Kate Steinle Shooting Defense Wants Gun Possession . Related posts to kate steinle shooting defense wants gun possession .

A jury last week found Jose Ines Garcia Zarate, 45, guilty of a lesser count of being a felon in possession of a gun in connection with Steinle’s death on Pier 14 in July 2015, after the defense argued at trial that the shooting was an accident that happened after the defendant found a stolen gun wrapped in a T-shirt or cloth under a bench.

Now the defense says the conviction is inconsistent with the jury’s larger acquittal. If the panel believed Steinle may have been killed by an accidental discharge, lawyers assert, Garcia Zarate should not be held responsible for possessing the weapon — even though he threw it in the bay as Steinle lay dying.

Matt Gonzalez of the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office, the lead attorney in the case, said he will appeal the charge at some point after Garcia Zarate’s Dec. 14 sentencing in Superior Court. Gonzalez said his appeal will contend jurors should have been told that “momentary” possession of a gun is not necessarily a crime.

Trump resumes calls for border wall in response to Kate Steinle murder trial verdict

  Trump resumes calls for border wall in response to Kate Steinle murder trial verdict President Trump early Friday resumed his criticism of the not guilty verdict for an undocumented immigrant charged with murder in the 2015 shooting death of Kate Steinle.In a series of early morning tweets, Trump called the verdict a "complete travesty," repeating his calls to build a border wall with Mexico and warning Democrats to take a tougher stance on immigration or pay the price in elections.

SAN FRANCISCO — In a move that could spark more national outrage, defense lawyers are urging a judge to throw out the one conviction in the Kate Steinle shooting trial. A momentary possession defense requires the defendant not be throwing away a gun in order to prevent police from retrieving it.

The illegal immigrant who was acquitted of Kate Steinle ’s murder is seeking a new trial to overturn his conviction on a firearm charge in the same case. At trial, Garcia Zarate admitted to firing the shot that killed Steinle , but the defense contended that the gun “went off” in his hands after he found it

“If you possess it just to dispose of it or abandon it, it wouldn’t be a crime,” he said.

San Francisco prosecutors, who declined to comment, argued at trial that Garcia Zarate fired toward Steinle intentionally, offering evidence that the pistol that killed the 32-year-old woman would discharge only with a firm pull of the trigger. The bullet bounced off the pier’s concrete ground before striking Steinle in the back and piercing her heart.

The defense said the gun went off in Garcia Zarate’s hands almost immediately after he found it, and that he flung it in the water because he was scared.

During deliberations, Gonzalez said, jurors asked Judge Samuel Feng about brief possession of the gun.

“We suspect the conviction on the gun charge is based on (Garcia Zarate’s actions) after the gun went off and he realized it was a gun and dumped it,” said Tamara Aparton, a spokeswoman for the Public Defender’s Office. “If it’s based on that, the jury did not get proper instruction on momentary possession.”

DOJ considering bringing charges against man found not guilty in Kate Steinle's murder

  DOJ considering bringing charges against man found not guilty in Kate Steinle's murder The Justice Department is considering bringing charges against the man found not guilty in Kate Steinle's murder, DOJ spokesperson Sarah Flores told CNN. Following last night's not guilty verdict by a California jury in San Francisco resident Steinle's murder, the DOJ is weighing whether it will take a separate action in bringing charges against Garcia Zarate. All available federal options are on the table, CNN is told.

Lawyers for illegal immigrant Jose Ines Garcia Zarate, who was acquitted in the shooting death of Kate Steinle , said Monday they will seek to have a judge toss his gun possession conviction .

Kate Steinle shooting : Defense wants gun - possession conviction tossed as well . FACT CHECK: Do Federal Charges In The Kate Steinle Case Count As Double Jeopardy? Mexican acquitted of murder faces gun, immigration charges.

Jurors did not explain their verdict publicly after handing it down, and in general they cannot be asked to explain deliberations to settle conflicts during appeals.

If an appeals court agrees with the defense argument and overturns the conviction, Garcia Zarate could be retried for that charge alone.

Showing an error was made during jury instructions isn’t necessarily enough to get a new trial. On appeal, the defense additionally has to show that the error affected the outcome, said Andrea Roth, an assistant professor of the UC Berkeley School of Law and a former appellate attorney for the Public Defender Service in Washington, D.C.

“You have to show the error mattered — that it wasn’t harmless,” she said.

In previous cases on appeal, Roth said, she’s argued an error wasn’t harmless by pointing to inconsistency in verdicts and suggesting the jury may have compromised — violating their instructions.

It’s unclear how the dispute could affect the fate of Garcia Zarate, who remains in San Francisco jail. He faces up to three years in state prison on the gun-possession charge, but he has likely already satisfied that term since his arrest shortly after the shooting. Federal authorities on Friday unsealed a warrant for his arrest, and they plan to deport him for a sixth time.

DOJ issues arrest warrant for undocumented immigrant acquitted in Kate Steinle killing

  DOJ issues arrest warrant for undocumented immigrant acquitted in Kate Steinle killing A federal warrant has been issued for the arrest of a Mexican immigrant acquitted Thursday evening of murder charges in the 2015 killing of Kate Steinle.Steinle's death has been taken up by opponents of so-called sanctuary cities. They argue that stricter immigration enforcement would have kept Jose Ines Garcia Zarate, who is residing in the U.S. illegally and was deported five separate times before the 2015 shooting, of f the streets.The arrest warrant unsealed in the Western District of Texas by the Justice Department on Friday accuses Zarate of violating his supervised release.

The illegal immigrant charged with felony possession of a firearm instead of Kate Steinle 's murder is seeking to have gun charges dismissed. Steinle was shot and killed on San Francisco’s Pier 14 on July 1, 2015.

Garcia Zarate has pending federal charges of violating the terms of his 2015 release from prison, where he had served 46 months for felony re-entry to the United States after deportation. He will be turned over to the U.S. Marshals Service when he is eligible for release in the Pier 14 case, Sheriff’s Department officials said.

The .40-caliber Sig Sauer pistol that Garcia Zarate allegedly possessed had been stolen four days earlier from a U.S. Bureau of Land Management ranger’s car after he drove into the city and parked along the Embarcadero. No one has been arrested in the burglary.

Garcia Zarate’s acquittal on the most serious charges shocked many observers and was called “disgraceful” and a “complete travesty of justice” by President Trump.

Before the shooting, Garcia Zarate had been on track for deportation, but his course changed when he was transferred from federal custody to San Francisco County Jail in March 2015 on an old warrant alleging he fled marijuana charges in 1995.

When city prosecutors discharged the case, the Sheriff’s Department released Garcia Zarate despite a federal request to hold him for deportation. Then-Sheriff Ross Mirkarimi cited the city’s sanctuary policies, which limit local cooperation with immigration enforcement and seek to encourage undocumented people to feel comfortable having a relationship with city agencies.

Evan Sernoffsky and Bob Egelko are San Francisco Chronicle staff writers. Email: esernoffsky@sfchronicle.com, begelko@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @EvanSernoffsky, @Egelko

RELATED VIDEO: Kate Steinle verdict reignites sanctuary cities debate (Video by CBS News)

  

Mexican acquitted of murder faces gun, immigration charges .
The Latest on San Francisco pier shooting charges (all times local):5:45 p.m.Federal authorities have charged a Mexican man with new immigration and gun violations less than a week after a San Francisco jury acquitted him of murder for the shooting death of Kate Steinle, a case that helped fuel a fierce national debate on immigration.A federal grand jury in San Francisco indicted Jose Ines Garcia Zarate Tuesday on one count each of felon in possession of a firearm and of "being an alien illegally and unlawfully in the United States" in possession of a gun and ammunition, according to the indictment.

Source: http://us.pressfrom.com/news/crime/-104358-kate-steinle-shooting-defense-wants-gun-possession-conviction-tossed-as-well/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!