Crime 'You took 32 years of my life': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID

17:06  11 july  2018
17:06  11 july  2018 Source:   latimes.com

Heavily armed men in helicopter free notorious French inmate

  Heavily armed men in helicopter free notorious French inmate A notorious French criminal serving 25 years for murder made an audacious escape from prison by helicopter. It was the second daring escape by Redoine Faid, who once blasted his way out of a different prison with explosives hidden in tissue packs.

A civil rights lawsuit filed by Andrew Wilson accuses an LAPD detective of influencing a key witness to falsely identify him as a murderer and underscores a continuing controversy in the way many After 32 years behind bars, man walks free to meet jubilant family after judge throws out murder conviction.

Wilson's lawsuit against the former detective , as well as the city and county of Los Angeles , alleges that Marks' actions were unconstitutional and that the district attorney's office for years failed to protect the rights of criminal suspects. " You took 32 years of my life ," Wilson said during a recent interview.

a man sitting on a cutting board: Andrew Wilson, left, exchanges a fist bump with his attorney Adam Grant at the start of a hearing in Los Angeles Superior Court that determined that he will be set free after serving 32-years of a life term for homicide March 15, 2017. Wilson's case was taken up by Loyola Law School's Project For the Innocent, and found glaring errors were made by the detective's investigation. © Provided by MarkBoster/Los Angeles Times/TNS Andrew Wilson, left, exchanges a fist bump with his attorney Adam Grant at the start of a hearing in Los Angeles Superior Court that determined that he will be set free after serving 32-years of a life term for homicide March 15, 2017. Wilson's case was taken up by Loyola Law School's Project For the Innocent, and found glaring errors were made by the detective's investigation.

LOS ANGELES - The teenager stared at 16 mug shots, searching for the face of the man had who stabbed her boyfriend to death while they slept in his pickup truck in South L.A.

It was November 1984 - a month after the slaying - and Saladena Bishop already had pointed police toward two suspects who were quickly ruled out. Now, Los Angeles police Detective Richard Marks had a new photo lineup, and he drew her attention to No. 7.

Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin Kiss Passionately in a NYC Garden -- See the Pic!

  Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin Kiss Passionately in a NYC Garden -- See the Pic! The two shared a steamy smooch after eating lunch together in Brooklyn, New York, over the weekend.Since rekindling their romance in recent weeks, the two haven't been shy about expressing their love in public, this time packing on the PDA in Brooklyn, New York.

A civil rights lawsuit filed by Andrew Wilson accuses an LAPD detective of influencing a key witness to falsely identify him as a murderer and underscores a continuing controversy in the way many police agencies handle eyewitness identifications . Wilson's conviction was thrown out 32 years later.

Los Angeles police are investigating the disappearance of the original Iron Man suit worn by Robert Downey Jr. from a Pacoima warehouse, officials said Wednesday morning. ' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID .

"What about him?" the detective asked, referring to a picture of Andrew Wilson.

Bishop said that was the man - she was nearly certain, according to Marks.

Wilson, who always maintained his innocence, was convicted and sentenced to life in prison in a case that relied almost entirely on the witness's identification. More than three decades passed before a judge in 2017 threw out the conviction and freed him.

A civil rights lawsuit filed this week by Wilson, 63, accuses Marks of leading the witness to falsely identify him as a killer - and underscores a continuing controversy over the way many police agencies handle eyewitness identifications.

The age-old police method of asking someone to pick a suspect from a lineup has fallen under increasing scrutiny in recent years and shoulders some of the blame for hundreds of wrongful convictions across the country. The straightforward witness direction by Marks has drawn sharp criticism from prosecutors, defense attorneys and eyewitness memory experts.

Lawsuit: Armed Cops Forced Domestic-Violence Victims to Make Fight Videos

  Lawsuit: Armed Cops Forced Domestic-Violence Victims to Make Fight Videos One sex-crimes detective is accused of assaulting a shooting survivor more than 50 times.But Large, who died earlier this year, had more than just one dark secret during his 27-year tenure at the South Carolina police department.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . Under state law, salaries for police and firefighters are tax- free while they are on injury leave. Nothing will change until the new study is complete, Garcetti said.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . LAPD seeks public's help to identify boy found alone at Union Station.

Wilson's lawsuit against the former detective, as well as the city and county of Los Angeles, alleges that Marks' actions were unconstitutional and that the district attorney's office for years failed to protect the rights of criminal suspects.

"You took 32 years of my life," Wilson said during a recent interview. "You can't give that back to me."

Last year, a record 37 people were exonerated in cases based, at least in part, on bad eyewitness identifications, according to a national database.

To address the problem, a California commission more than a decade ago urged police to stop having lead detectives show witnesses an array of photographs of possible suspects side by side. Instead, the panel recommended adopting a "double-blind" procedure, in which an officer who doesn't know which picture belongs to the suspect shows the witness a series of photographs one after the other.

'Gundam' Live-Action Movie in the Works at Legendary

  'Gundam' Live-Action Movie in the Works at Legendary The popular anime series first launched in 1979.Legendary Entertainment will co-produce a feature based on the the popular anime from the Japanese animation studio Sunrise. The announcement was made Thursday at the 2018 Anime Expo, which is taking place in Los Angeles.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . Many of them did not know what a police officer is, and the 17-year-old who escaped did not know what medication or pills are, Hestrin said.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . Strangers sent her dozens of tips about men they suspected in their own lives — roommates and former friends. One man told her he used to break into houses with a burglar who admitted he'd been

Advocates of the method say it prevents officers from even unconsciously steering a witness to a particular photograph. Several law enforcement agencies, including those in North Carolina and New Jersey, as well as the San Francisco Police Department and law enforcement in Santa Clara County, have switched to the method. But others, including the LAPD, have been reluctant to adopt the double-blind method and still allow case investigators to handle lineups.

Earlier this year, labor unions representing prosecutors and the LAPD's rank-and-file opposed a bill that would require the practice.

The police union said it believes the proposed law would lead to fewer solved crimes, arguing that witnesses and victims "will be unwilling to freely offer information to anyone they do not know, trust or feel comfortable with," according to state documents.

The way Marks directed the witness to Wilson's photo - a practice he said he used at times throughout his career - is an overt example of how eyewitness identification can go wrong, said Gary L. Wells, an Iowa State University psychology professor who has studied the practice for decades.

LAPD detective's use of the N-word roils infamous gang murder case

  LAPD detective's use of the N-word roils infamous gang murder case At a Little Tokyo bar, drinks fueled a heated discussion among a group of lawyers and a Los Angeles police investigator. Then talk turned to police corruption.Veteran LAPD Detective Brian McCartin told his three companions about his experience encountering black gang members. He referred to them using the N-word."What, you've never used that word in the privacy of your own living room?" he asked when the slur was met with shock, according to court documents.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . La triste y surrealista historia del aclamado documental ‘Three Identical Strangers’. Dangerous heat wave to hit Southern California this weekend.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . Colin Firth and wife Livia Giuggioli reach settlement with ex-lover accused of stalking.

"The problems here are legion," Wells said. "He's just completely giving out his hypothesis that that's the guy we're focused on."

Witnesses, he said, "tend to think that police know the answer, and they're there to help provide confirmation."

In an interview with the Los Angeles Times, Marks defended his handling of Wilson's case, saying he made clear notes in the official record about having directed the witness. The retired detective said he has read literature on eyewitness identification in recent years and agrees it has limitations, but doesn't think his actions led to a false identification.

"I certainly have a clear conscience," he said.

After his retirement in 2008, Marks did consulting work for the district attorney's office, reviewing evidence and offering his opinion in at least two high-profile police shootings - which ultimately ended in prosecutors declining to file charges against the officers in either case.

The district attorney's office declined to comment, citing the pending litigation; the LAPD did not respond to a request for comment.

From behind bars, Wilson in 1999 filed an official complaint about Marks with the LAPD, according to the lawsuit.

But the first sign of hope didn't come until August 2014, when he got a letter from a deputy federal public defender. The attorney wrote that he represented another man serving life for murder, and that an eyewitness had recently recanted, saying Marks and his partner had coerced a false identification. Marks denied any wrongdoing in that case.

What 3 ‘Big Brother’ Winners Did After Their $500K Payday

  What 3 ‘Big Brother’ Winners Did After Their $500K Payday The CBS reality series “Big Brother” has a slogan: Expect the unexpected. Show winners Dan Gheesling, Ian Terry and Derrick Levasseur lived that motto firsthand. After spending months in a…After spending months in a house filled with television cameras and strangers, the three each won a season of the show and walked away with the $500,000 grand prize.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . Colin Firth and wife Livia Giuggioli reach settlement with ex-lover accused of stalking.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . Boy found alone at Union Station; LAPD seeks public's help to identify him.

Not long after, the attorney visited Wilson in prison and alerted Loyola Law School's innocence project, which championed the case.

Loyola lawyers tracked down the trial prosecutor, Laura Aalto, who in July 2016 signed a declaration saying she'd long felt "uneasy" about the prosecution. Aalto wrote that during Wilson's trial, she wasn't aware Marks had directed the witness during the photo lineup.

"I do not know," she wrote, "how any detective could have thought that was a legitimate way to conduct an identification procedure, even in 1984."

Five months later, Marks sat down for a recorded interview with Wilson's lawyers and a deputy district attorney.

The detective said he considered Wilson a "thug," clarifying he meant someone who committed crimes to support a drug habit. During the interview, the prosecutor asked Marks what he had meant years earlier, when he wrote in an affidavit that he had "directed" the eyewitness to Wilson's photo.

"Just exactly what is says," Marks responded, saying he asked her to look at a picture of Wilson and asked something along the lines of "What about him?"

Marks said he intentionally made a record of having directed the witness, as he figured it would be an issue requiring litigation before trial. In the affidavit attached to an arrest warrant, Marks wrote that he had included photographs of Wilson and another man, who was initially arrested as a co-defendant. While looking at the photos, Marks wrote, the witness "hesitated" over a photo of the other man, saying she would need to see a live lineup.

LA Times protests judge’s order to change article

  LA Times protests judge’s order to change article The Los Angeles Times is protesting a federal judge's order to remove information from an article the newspaper published on Saturday morning, according to the LA Times.U.S. District Judge John F. Walter on Saturday ordered the Times to delete certain details from an article about a Glendale police detective accused of working with the Mexican Mafia.The Times said they will contest this order, calling it an unusual violation of the First Amendment."We believe that once material is in the public record, it is proper and appropriate to publish it if it is newsworthy," Norman Pearlstine, executive editor of the Times, said.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . The two men are parents to Ethan, a precocious 13-year-old known in the flat, clay and pine country as the only kid in school with two gay dads.

' You took 32 years of my life ': Freed man accuses LAPD detective of manipulating eyewitness ID . "We have a primal need for our grief to be witnessed . Our psyche doesn't want us to be an island of grief.

"She then eliminated several other photos," Marks wrote, adding that he then "directed her attention to Wilson's photo, which she then identified with 80 percent confidence."

During an interview this week, Marks stressed that a judge ultimately signed the arrest warrant and that his affidavit was in the case documents he gave the prosecutor.

"This isn't something that was buried," he said.

Wilson's lawsuit contends that the defense never got a copy of Marks' affidavit, but the retired detective said he "can't conceive" of that notion, saying he recalled one of Wilson's attorneys coming to the police station with a portable device to make copies of sections of the case evidence. (The attorney, Jim Barnes, doesn't specifically recall the case, but said neither he nor his office had portable copiers during the 1980s, according to the lawsuit.)

During the 2016 interview with the Loyola lawyers, Marks said that at a subsequent live lineup, Bishop recalled that she knew Wilson's face from before - she had babysat for his daughter, records show.

Was it possible, the prosecutor asked, that the witness identified Wilson because she'd recognized him from earlier?

"Is it a possibility?" Marks said. "Yeah."

"Were you concerned about that?" the prosecutor asked.

"I wouldn't say that I was concerned," Marks said.

When Wilson got out of prison, he felt joy but also crushing sadness and fear. He thought about the people he'd lost while incarcerated - a sister, his eldest grandson - and decided to move to St. Louis to be near his 98-year-old mother. He applied for jobs, but didn't hear back.

When he finally got work mopping floors at a chemical lab, he often showed up to his shift two hours early. He wanted his co-workers to see him - if anyone came asking, he'd have an alibi. But he recently slipped on the job and hurt his lower back, so he has missed a lot of work for doctor's appointments, Wilson said.

His adult daughter, who lives in Michigan, calls 10 to 12 times a day to check in.

The hardest part, Wilson says, is the debilitating fear that authorities will target him again. He often wakes up in a panic in the middle of the night.

On a recent afternoon - when it was 85 degrees outside and he had a full tank of gas in his car - he told himself he really should be outside at the park with his girlfriend.

Instead, he holed up inside. He doesn't run errands when it's dark outside, and the sight of a patrol car sparks a panic attack - his heart races and his breathing gets short.

"That fear will always be in me," he says. "I don't want be on the other end of that again. I just can't. I don't have 32 more years to give."

He thinks about Marks every day - and about the other people the detective investigated. During his long career with the LAPD, Marks was listed as a possible witness in at least 40 criminal cases, according to the district attorney's office.

"He gets a pension," Wilson said, "and the best I could get was a job mopping floors?"

Visit the Los Angeles Times at www.latimes.com

Judge lifts controversial order requiring the L.A. Times to alter article about ex-Glendale cop .
A federal judge Tuesday lifted a controversial order requiring the Los Angeles Times to remove information in an article about a former Glendale police detective accused of working with the Mexican Mafia. U.S. District Judge John F. Walter had issued the order Saturday after The Times published information on its website about a plea agreement between prosecutors and the former detective. The agreement had been sealed by the court but was placed in a court database of documents accessible to the public.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
This is interesting!