Opinion The Decline of Anti-Trumpism

17:39  10 january  2018
17:39  10 january  2018 Source:   The New York Times

Bernie Sanders resolves to ‘intensify the struggle against Trumpism’ in 2018

  Bernie Sanders resolves to ‘intensify the struggle against Trumpism’ in 2018 Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) late Sunday shared his New Year's resolution: to "intensify the struggle against Trumpism." "In 2018, we will not only intensify the struggle against Trumpism, we will increase our efforts to spread the progressive vision in every corner of the land," Sanders tweeted.

The Decline of Anti - Trumpism . David Brooks JAN. A version of this op-ed appears in print on January 9, 2018, on Page A23 of the New York edition with the headline: The Decline of Anti - Trumpism .

David Brooks describes himself as a “proud member” of “the anti-Trump movement” in his latest column for The New York Times, but as the title suggests—“ The Decline of Anti - Trumpism ”—he’s ashamed of what’s become of the president’s opposition.

person holding a sign: Anti-Trump lowbrowism burst into full bloom with the new Michael Wolff book. © Carlos Barria/Reuters Anti-Trump lowbrowism burst into full bloom with the new Michael Wolff book.

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

Let me start with three inconvenient observations, based on dozens of conversations around Washington over the past year:

First, people who go into the White House to have a meeting with President Trump usually leave pleasantly surprised. They find that Trump is not the raving madman they expected from his tweetstorms or the media coverage. They generally say that he is affable, if repetitive. He runs a normal, good meeting and seems well-informed enough to get by.

New York to close first part of Rikers Island in 2018

  New York to close first part of Rikers Island in 2018 New York is to close the first of nine facilities that make up the notorious prison of Rikers Island this summer, Mayor Bill de Blasio said Wednesday. The Democratic mayor hopes to one day close the entire prison, located on an island in the East River and infamous for its harsh conditions and violence.Rikers currently houses 8,705 inmates, the lowest number since 1982. The first Rikers section to close will be the George Motchan detention facility, which houses 600 inmates, the department of corrections said."Every day we are making New York City’s jail system smaller and safer," said the mayor on his Twitter account.

The decline of anti - Trumpism . The anti-Trump movement suffers from insularity. Most of the people who detest Trump don't know anybody who works with him or supports him.

President Donald Trump listens during a meeting with lawmakers on immigration policy in the Cabinet Room of the White House, Tuesday, Jan. 9, 2018, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci) DCEV108.

Sign up for the Morning Briefing Newsletter.

Second, people who work in the Trump administration have wildly divergent views about their boss. Some think he is a deranged child, as Michael Wolff reported. But some think he is merely a distraction they can work around. Some think he is strange, but not impossible. Some genuinely admire Trump. Many filter out his crazy stuff and pretend it doesn’t exist.

My impression is that the Trump administration is an unhappy place to work, because there is a lot of infighting and often no direction from the top. But this is not an administration full of people itching to invoke the 25th Amendment.

Third, the White House is getting more professional. Imagine if Trump didn’t tweet. The craziness of the past weeks would be out of the way, and we’d see a White House that is briskly pursuing its goals: the shift in our Pakistan policy, the shift in our offshore drilling policy, the fruition of our ISIS policy, the nomination for judgeships and the formation of policies on infrastructure, DACA, North Korea and trade.

What Was Steve Bannon Thinking?

  What Was Steve Bannon Thinking? Donald Trump hired Steve Bannon as his campaign manager, gave him a job in the White House, and signed an executive order to give him a seat at meetings of the National Security Council’s principals committee, giving him access to some of America’s most sensitive secrets, even as his erstwhile adviser helped to make him the most powerful man on earth. But now the two are fighting as if they find one another deplorable and irredeemable.Bannon is quoted savaging multiple members of the Trump family in excerpts from a forthcoming book by the journalist Michael Wolff.

David Brooks: The decline of anti - Trumpism . President Donald Trump listens during a meeting with lawmakers on immigration policy in the Cabinet Room of the White House, Tuesday, Jan. 9, 2018, in Washington.

Anti -Trump lowbrowism burst into full bloom with the new Michael Wolff book.CreditCarlos Barria/Reuters.

It’s almost as if there are two White Houses. There’s the Potemkin White House, which we tend to focus on: Trump berserk in front of the TV, the lawyers working the Russian investigation and the press operation. Then there is the Invisible White House that you never hear about, which is getting more effective at managing around the distracted boss.

I sometimes wonder if the Invisible White House has learned to use the Potemkin White House to deke us while it changes the country.

I mention these inconvenient observations because the anti-Trump movement, of which I’m a proud member, seems to be getting dumber. It seems to be settling into a smug, fairy tale version of reality that filters out discordant information. More anti-Trumpers seem to be telling themselves a “Madness of King George” narrative: Trump is a semiliterate madman surrounded by sycophants who are morally, intellectually and psychologically inferior to people like us.

What Donald Trump Set On Fire When He Burned Steve Bannon

  What Donald Trump Set On Fire When He Burned Steve Bannon Donald Trump's spectacular disavowal of Steve Bannon isn't just the end for Bannon. It's the end for Bannon's attempt to turn 'Trumpism' into a movement.There's a nasty cold snap hitting the East Coast, but at least its impact will be mitigated by the heat generated when Donald Trump set Steve Bannon on fire.

Anti -Trump lowbrowism burst into full bloom with the new Michael Wolff book.CreditCarlos Barria/Reuters.

The following are excerpts from Brooks’ moment of clarity entitled “ The Decline of Anti - Trumpism ”: Let me start with three inconvenient observations, based on dozens of conversations around Washington over the past year

I’d like to think it’s possible to be fervently anti-Trump while also not reducing everything to a fairy tale.

The anti-Trump movement suffers from insularity. Most of the people who detest Trump don’t know anybody who works with him or supports him. And if they do have friends and family members who admire Trump, they’ve learned not to talk about this subject. So they get most of their information about Trumpism from others who also detest Trumpism, which is always a recipe for epistemic closure.

The movement also suffers from lowbrowism. Fox News pioneered modern lowbrowism. The modern lowbrow (think Sean Hannity or Dinesh D’Souza) ignores normal journalistic or intellectual standards. He creates a style of communication that doesn’t make you think more; it makes you think and notice less. He offers a steady diet of affirmation, focuses on simple topics that require little background information, and gets viewers addicted to daily doses of righteous contempt and delicious vindication.

We anti-Trumpers have our lowbrowism, too, mostly on late-night TV. But anti-Trump lowbrowism burst into full bloom with the Wolff book.

Saudi arrests 11 princes over anti-austerity protest: media

  Saudi arrests 11 princes over anti-austerity protest: media Saudi authorities have arrested 11 princes who protested against the kingdom's austerity measures and who could face trial, a news website close to the government reported on Saturday. Sabq said the princes, who were not named, were protesting at a historical Riyadh royal palace, Qasr al-Hokm, against a government's decision to stop paying the water and electricity bills of royals.They were also demanding "financial compensation" after one of their cousins had been sentenced for an unspecified crime.

With the escalating decline in U.S. influence from the Bush administration through Obama and now to Trump, U.S. global dominance increasingly depends on its ability to project military power. Therefore, anti - Trumpism does not include a position against war and U.S. imperialism.

Wherever similar social conditions exist--economic decline , a mistrusted state, and traditions of bigotry and discrimination-- Trumpism or something like it does, too. In Europe, most countries are facing economic hardship that is measurably worse than in the U.S.--and the forces of anti -establishment

Wolff doesn’t pretend to adhere to normal journalistic standards. He happily admits that he’s just tossing out rumors that are too good to check. As Charlie Warzel wrote on BuzzFeed, “For Wolff’s book, the truth seems almost a secondary concern to what really matters: engagement.”

The ultimate test of the lowbrow is not whether it challenges you, teaches you or captures the contours of reality; it’s whether you feel an urge to share it on social media.

In every war, nations come to resemble their enemies, so I suppose it’s normal that the anti-Trump movement would come to resemble the pro-Trump movement. But it’s not good. I’ve noticed a lot of young people look at the monotonous daily hysteria of we anti-Trumpers and they find it silly.

This isn’t just a struggle over a president. It’s a struggle over what rules we’re going to play by after Trump. Are we all going to descend permanently into the Trump standard of acceptable behavior?

Or, are we going to restore the distinction between excellence and mediocrity, truth and a lie? Are we going to insist on the difference between a genuine expert and an ill-informed blow hard? Are we going to restore the distinction between those institutions like the Congressional Budget Office that operate by professional standards and speak with legitimate authority, and the propaganda mills that don’t?

There’s a hierarchy of excellence in every sphere. There’s a huge difference between William F. Buckley and Sean Hannity, between the reporters at this newspaper and a rumor-spreader. Part of this struggle is to maintain those distinctions, not to contribute to their evisceration.

Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook and Twitter (@NYTopinion), and sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter.

Democrats, give moderate GOP voters a reason to lean your way .
Part of the reason Democrats’ message has fallen short with Republican voters is they have treated them as a monolith. But they’re not.Load Error

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!