Opinion Why Republicans will never reform immigration

19:56  14 may  2018
19:56  14 may  2018 Source:   theweek.com

Trump promotes 'America First' in Ohio ahead of primaries

  Trump promotes 'America First' in Ohio ahead of primaries President Donald Trump has promoted his "America First" agenda during an appearance in Cleveland. Trump spent several hours in Ohio on Saturday meeting with supporters and participating in a roundtable designed to highlight the benefits of the new Republican tax law. Striking a celebratory tone, Trump listed his poll numbers and recounted the successes of his first year in office. He also looked ahead to his meeting with North Korea's Kim Jong Un.Trump spent several hours in Ohio meeting with supporters and participating in a roundtable designed to highlight the benefits of the new Republican tax law. Striking a celebratory tone, Trump listed his poll numbers and recounted the successes of his first year in office.

Why are Republicans so concerned with the Hispanic vote? They have never done well with Hispanics and won’t no matter what they support and pass on immigration reform .

Never mind the GOP's anti- immigrant rhetoric; they need Latino voting power to win future elections. Judging from the cold shoulder conservative Republicans gave President Bush when he called for a humane, balanced immigration reform law in a recent speech in Orange County, Calif

President Donald Trump and his wall. © MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images President Donald Trump and his wall.

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not necessarily represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

The Republican Party is never going to reform immigration. And it isn't just because of President Trump. The party's other leaders have decided that immigration is something you can talk about, use as an electoral wedge issue, or bang your fist about. But there will be no attempt to actually make policy on it, at least not anything that resembles the "reform" we've been promised for years.

House Republicans, Defying Leaders, Move to Force Immigration Votes

  House Republicans, Defying Leaders, Move to Force Immigration Votes More than a dozen House Republicans created a petition to force votes on immigration legislation, hoping to settle the uncertain futures of the so-called Dreamers.WASHINGTON — More than a dozen House Republicans defied Speaker Paul D. Ryan on Wednesday and moved to force a vote on immigration in the House, aiming to settle the uncertain futures of so-called Dreamers, young immigrants who were brought to this country illegally as children.

Never mind the GOP's anti- immigrant rhetoric; they need Latino voting power to win future elections. Health Policy Expert Says Republicans Have 'Secret' Plan to Repeal Obamacare.

Republicans who believe they can never persuade people who don’t currently support them to vote for the GOP will likely vote against immigration reform . Jeb Bush put it succinctly: “If the argument is all is lost, then all is lost.”.

We saw that clearly last week, when a small group of Republicans — "Most, but not all, represent swing districts with significant Latino constituencies or are retiring from the House," as The Washington Post noted — started a bit of a rebellion, attempting to get votes on the House floor on immigration reform proposals. They were trying to do it via a "discharge petition," a parliamentary technique that involves getting a majority of members to overrule the speaker of the House, who controls the schedule, and force a vote.

But Paul Ryan was having none of it. "Having some kind of spectacle on the floor that results in a veto doesn't solve this problem," he said. "What I don't want to do is have a process that just ends up with a veto. We actually want to solve the DACA problem."

Young GOP lawmakers push for fresh approach

  Young GOP lawmakers push for fresh approach Younger lawmakers in the House GOP conference are pressing their leadership for a fresh approach on policy and messaging, arguing it will help Republicans win over young voters going forward. A group of more than a dozen lawmakers has been meeting informally to discuss how to attract younger voters, though they aren't necessarily united on every policy issue.Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-Wis.), 34, has introduced legislation to impose term limits on members, while Rep. Mia Love (R-Utah), 42, talks of the importance of making contraception more available.Rep. Scott Taylor (R-Va.

And his analysis explains why Republicans have had the same health policy strategy for 20 years: Nominally favoring big Conservative health reformers would take the blame for all the problems their reforms created, and many problems they didn't, just as has happened to liberals with Obamacare.

Republicans turned their backs on immigration reform in part because Democratic leadership and the White House believed that House Republicans would take on a more conservative bill than the Senate did.

But does he?

It depends on your definition of "want." I'm sure that in some corner of Republican lawmakers' hearts there is a bit of sympathy for DREAMers, the young people brought here as children who have done everything right and now face the prospect of deportation. President Trump, for instance, has talked many times about how he'll treat those terrific kids with compassion. But he also canceled the DACA program. And he has lamented the fact that we get so many immigrants from "shithole countries," arguing that "we should have more people from places like Norway." His chief of staff, John Kelly, says that the trouble with undocumented immigrants is that they're "not people that would easily assimilate into the United States, into our modern society."

The very fact that Trump is president shows why his party is incapable of reforming immigration, or ever coming to some sort of grand bargain of the type that has often been suggested, in which he'd get funding for his border wall and Democrats would get protection for DREAMers.

Trump speaks at White House discussion on prison reform

  Trump speaks at White House discussion on prison reform The president has taken a tough-on-crime approach to officeLoad Error

Immigration reform means, to you, comrade socialist If illegals were more likely to vote republican , they would have been rounded up and deported years ago. Why are you lying about it? (as always) They NEVER SAID he "didn’t do anything on immigration ," they say he isn't doing anything GOOD. >

The Democrat party does not embrace immigration reform because they love illegal aliens. If Democrats get a chance to do this, Republicans will never get the votes of current illegal immigrants .

After the 2012 election, the party commissioned an "autopsy" to figure out where it should go next. "We must embrace and champion comprehensive immigration reform," it said. "If we do not, our party's appeal will continue to shrink to its core constituencies only." It also said that "the Republican Party is one of tolerance and respect, and we need to ensure that the tone of our message is always reflective of these core principles."

Then Donald Trump came along and said, Oh yeah? Well, get a load of this.

It's important to remember that the crowded field of Republican candidates Trump joined in 2015 were dancing carefully around the immigration issue. They knew it was tricky: The base didn't like anything that could be characterized as "amnesty" for undocumented immigrants, but they needed to look reasonable and moderate for the general election.

But Trump, who has a sixth sense for the most rancid poison swirling about in the voters' id, realized they were all wrong. Forget about what the broader electorate says they want: The road to victory, he realized, was paved with hate and fear. He was different from the rest of the GOP contenders in many ways, but more than anything else he was the one that presented the most unadorned version of white nationalism on offer.

GOP lawmakers want Trump to stop bashing Congress

  GOP lawmakers want Trump to stop bashing Congress Senate Republicans want President Trump to stop taking jabs at Congress over its inability to get things done. Trump loves to tout results and bash lawmakers when they do not move fast enough on his priorities.

In 2007, that moment came for immigration reform . There was a bipartisan bill by Sens. "I never saw him engage in any discussion concerned with building a majority in favor of the legislation." When Republicans passed their historic tax reform package in late 2017, they also repealed the

Even stronger than this demographic and pragmatic argument for why Republicans should support comprehensive immigration reform though, is an ideological one. Frankly, Republican arguments against immigration reform reek of protectionism, which has never been the way of the GOP.

It wasn't an act, and it got him both the nomination and the presidency. But it goes beyond Trump. Imagine that he decided not to run for re-election, and a passel of GOP senators and governors tried to lead the party in 2020. Do you think any of them would propose comprehensive immigration reform? Would they be foolish enough to think that they could win over the party's base that way?

For Republicans in Congress, the calculation is much the same. There are some that favor it publicly, but most Republicans represent districts and states where their biggest fear is a primary challenge from the right — and nothing will get you that challenge quicker than going soft on the foreign horde.

The events of the last year and a half were predictable: the canceling of the DACA program, a wider immigration crackdown, and the occasional insincere assurance from Republicans that they really do want to do comprehensive reform — eventually. Just not now.

So if you're waiting for it — and some people are with their very lives at stake — the bad news is that you're going to have to wait until there's a Democratic president and a Democratic Congress. And even then, Republicans are going to put up a fight.

The Latest: Trump resumes feud with Pelosi over 'animals' .
The Latest on the dispute over immigration in the House (all times local):8:25 p.m.President Donald Trump is attacking House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi over her criticism of his decision to publicly brand MS-13 gang members "animals" during a White House meeting on immigration last week.Trump says: "Just the other day, Nancy Pelosi came out in favor of MS-13. She wants them to be treated with respect." He is speaking at the Susan B. Anthony List's annual Campaign for Life Gala.Pelosi did not endorse the gang, but took aim at Trump's rhetoric, saying, "Calling people animals is not a good thing."She added that "we all have to recognizeLoad Error

Source: http://us.pressfrom.com/news/opinion/-144776-why-republicans-will-never-reform-immigration/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!