US Can a lawyer defy his client and say he's guilty? SCOTUS to decide.

20:06  12 january  2018
20:06  12 january  2018 Source:   nbcnews.com

Rand Paul on neighbor attack: 'I still have pain every day'

  Rand Paul on neighbor attack: 'I still have pain every day' Sen. Rand Paul said Wednesday he's still in intense pain after a run-in with his Kentucky neighbor in November that resulted in him having six broken ribs and bruised lungs. "I still have pain every day, all day," the Kentucky Republican told CNN's Wolf Blitzer. "But I don't have -- I had the pain of 1,000 knives for about six weeks. I could barely move and barely breathe. I couldn't sleep. And so I am better than I was, but I won't say I'm back to normal yet. But I am getting better.

112396- can - a - lawyer - defy - his - client - and - say -hes- guilty - scotus - to - decide /. How do lawyers feel about defending clients they believe to be guilty ? - www.quora.com. "It' s not like I have a choice, do I?" he said bitterly, refusing to raise his head to meet my eyes.

The U. S . Supreme Court will hear arguments on a case in which Robert McCoy said he was innocent of murder but lawyer Larry English told the jury he was guilty . But his lawyer , Larry English, saw the case as unwinnable, and decided to focus on sparing McCoy from execution.

Image: Robert McCoyRobert McCoy, who faces the death penalty for a triple murder. © Provided by NBCU News Group, a division of NBCUniversal Media LLC Image: Robert McCoyRobert McCoy, who faces the death penalty for a triple murder. On trial for his life, Robert McCoy claimed he was the innocent victim of a police conspiracy ─ despite a mountain of evidence that he had killed three members of his estranged wife's family in northwestern Louisiana.

But his lawyer, Larry English, saw the case as unwinnable, and decided to focus on sparing McCoy from execution. English outlined his strategy: admit guilt from the start, then ask the jury for mercy.

McCoy refused. English insisted. They argued, behind closed doors, before the judge and in front of the jury. McCoy tried to fire English, but the judge said it was too late. In August 2011, the jury convicted McCoy of first-degree murder, and sentenced him to die.

Trump Lawyer Arranged $130,000 Payment for Adult-Film Star's Silence

  Trump Lawyer Arranged $130,000 Payment for Adult-Film Star's Silence A lawyer for President Donald Trump arranged a $130,000 payment to a former adult-film star a month before the 2016 election as part of an agreement that precluded her from publicly discussing an alleged sexual encounter with Mr. Trump, according to people familiar with the matter. Michael Cohen, who spent nearly a decade as a top attorney at the Trump Organization, arranged payment to the woman, Stephanie Clifford, in October 2016 after her lawyer negotiated the nondisclosure agreement with Mr. Cohen, these people said.Ms. Clifford, whose stage name is Stormy Daniels, has privately alleged the encounter with Mr.

Can a Lawyer Declare His Client Guilty ? The Supreme Court considered whether lawyers can decide what is best for clients and ignore their wishes. He conceded guilt because he was trying to save his client , Robert McCoy, from almost certain death.

A lawyer simply cannot ethically tell a jury that his client is guilty when the client has ordered him not to. Needless to say (well, needless everywhere but Louisiana!), English wasn’t abiding when he did the exact opposite of what his client decided he wanted to do.

More than six years later, McCoy sits on Louisiana's death row and is still fighting. He wants a new trial, arguing that his constitutional rights as a criminal defendant ─ specifically, the ability to mount his own defense ─ were violated. On Wednesday, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments on the case, which explores the boundaries of two tenets of the American justice system: the adversarial relationship between the government and the accused, and a defendant's ability to make decisions about his fate.

The plan English embraced is not uncommon in today's courtrooms. Defense lawyers often choose to concede that their client is guilty to avoid a worse outcome. It happens often in death penalty cases, when the defendant appears likely to be convicted, and the same jury charged with deciding guilt also chooses punishment. In those cases, the lawyer may decide that it would appear insincere to argue in the first phase that the defendant didn't commit the crime, then turn around and ask for leniency.

Ex-death row inmate pleads not guilty in trafficking case

  Ex-death row inmate pleads not guilty in trafficking case DOVER, Del. — A former death row inmate from Delaware who was later exonerated has pleaded not guilty to sex trafficking charges in Hawaii. The Delaware State News in Dover reported Saturday that Isaiah Otis Wilmont McCoy entered the plea in federal court. He's facing similar charges on the local level in Honolulu.McCoy was arrested Jan. 3 before being indicted federally Jan. 4. Authorities claim he forced a woman into prostitution among other charges, according to the report. He remains in jail.Federal authorities said McCoy denies the sex trafficking charges to investigators.

A LAWYER who was representing a man accused of murder defied his client ’ s wishes and submitted a guilty plea, telling the court his client was crazy. The Court said that, in certain circumstances, a lawyer can concede guilt despite their client ’ s wishes.

" He stood up and said he was tired, he had had a long week and he would see us in the morning," said John Poindexter Despite the fact that his plea is not expected to be taken up, commentators believe that the case provides SCOTUS a vehicle to further restrict a state ' s right to control private property.

Related: How America's justice system runs on the exchange of money for freedom

"The stakes get really high when what you're facing is a likely guilty verdict with a likely death penalty, especially when you say 'I didn't do it,'" said Ernie Lewis, executive director of the National Association for Public Defense.

Typically the client goes along with the plan.

McCoy, accused of fatally shooting his estranged wife's mother, stepfather and teen-age son in May 2008, wanted nothing to do with it.

"Your Honor, this is unconstitutional for you to keep an attorney on my case when this attorney is completely selling me out."

English, who had been hired by McCoy's parents and was not certified to try capital cases, told the Bossier Parish jury in his opening statement that "Mr. McCoy committed these crimes." English called his client "crazy" and argued for a lighter verdict of second-degree murder.

'Chelsea bomber' tried to radicalize fellow inmates, U.S. prosecutors say

  'Chelsea bomber' tried to radicalize fellow inmates, U.S. prosecutors say <p>The New Jersey man found guilty last year of planting two homemade bombs in Manhattan's Chelsea neighborhood, one of which wounded 30 people, has tried to radicalize fellow inmates with Islamic State and al Qaeda propaganda, U.S. prosecutors said on Tuesday.</p>The New Jersey man found guilty last year of planting two homemade bombs in Manhattan's Chelsea neighborhood, one of which wounded 30 people, has tried to radicalize fellow inmates with Islamic State and al Qaeda propaganda, U.S. prosecutors said on Tuesday.

The Supreme Court will decide Wednesday whether a lawyer may admit his client ’ s guilt to a jury, despite his objections. Before trial, English advised McCoy to enter a guilty plea, as the state would not seek the death penalty if he confessed to the crimes.

Now, it' s not really as simple as saying , “I can't represent you any longer”. The lawyer does require the court ’ s permission to recuse themselves, and such recusals must meet So even if a lawyer knows his client is guilty , he can put on evidence and argue that the state hasn't met its burden of proof.

McCoy interrupted.

"Your Honor, this is unconstitutional for you to keep an attorney on my case when this attorney is completely selling me out," he told the judge.

The trial continued. McCoy defied English and took the stand in his own defense, testifying that he was out of state at the time of the murders and blaming a police-led drug ring for committing them. Then English gave his closing arguments, saying that McCoy was guilty, but only of second-degree murder, because of mental deficiencies.

Image: Lawyer Larry English.Lawyer Larry English. © Provided by NBCU News Group, a division of NBCUniversal Media LLC Image: Lawyer Larry English.Lawyer Larry English.

Later, after McCoy was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to die, English reflected on his decisions in an affidavit. He said he'd become "convinced that the evidence against Robert McCoy was overwhelming" and that his client was paranoid and delusional.

"I felt that as along as I was his attorney of record it was my ethical duty to do what I thought was best to save his life even though what he wanted me to do was to get him acquitted in the guilt phase," English said.

Accused NY attacker's lawyers propose deal to avoid death penalty

  Accused NY attacker's lawyers propose deal to avoid death penalty <p>Lawyers for the Uzbek man accused of killing eight people by speeding a truck down a New York City bike path in October propos</p>Load Error

Can a lawyer who knows his client is guilty still successfully and legally defend the client ? I asked if he wanted to take the offer. "It' s not like I have a choice, do I?" he said bitterly, refusing to raise his head to meet my eyes.

S . 1, 7–8 (1966) (observing that a lawyer must not “override his client ’ s desire . . . to plead not guilty ”). The Sixth Circuit’ s conclusion to the contrary was error. We need not say more, and indeed we do not say more. I therefore join the Court ’ s opinion in full. I write separately, however, to express my

McCoy set about appealing his conviction, claiming he was denied his constitutional rights to the assistance of counsel and due process. The Louisiana Supreme Court ruled against him.

"Given the circumstances of this crime and the overwhelming evidence incriminating the defendant, admitting guilt in an attempt to avoid the imposition of the death penalty appears to constitute reasonable trial strategy," the Louisiana justices ruled.

Related: Louisiana is shedding its reputation as U.S.'s biggest jailer

The Louisiana court relied in part on a 2002 U.S. Supreme Court ruling on a Florida case that permitted a concession of guilt when a defendant was unresponsive to his lawyer's questions. But it did not address the situation in which a defendant explicitly disagrees ─ a test of the limits of a defendant's autonomy as outlined in the Constitution.

"A lawyer uses whatever strategies are available to them that are ethical and what the law permits him to do."

"It is inconceivable that the framers intended that the assistance of counsel should come at the price of defense counsel being authorized to tell the jury that the accused is guilty, even over the accused's protestations of his own innocence," Richard Bourke, director of the Louisiana Capital Assistance Center, wrote in McCoy's petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.

San Antonio, Texas man gets 99 years for 2015 ‘Hell’s Gate’ killing

  San Antonio, Texas man gets 99 years for 2015 ‘Hell’s Gate’ killing A San Antonio man found guilty last week in the 2015 fatal shooting of a man whose body was found in a West Side drainage ditch called “Hell’s Gate” has been sentenced to 99 years in prison.&nbsp;Robert Martinez was convicted of murder Friday. It took a jury about 90 minutes to decide on a sentence Wednesday morning. Martinez, 21, faced five to 99 years or life in prison.

That is, an attorney who defends a client he believes to be guilty does so willingly." Id. His lawyer comes up to me and starts asking me for an offer on him. I said , "If he ' s not willing to take the offer I've already made, then I'm going to take him to trial.

If the defendant disagrees with the lawyer ’ s decisions about strategy, and wants to have complete control over his defense, he should represent himself, which is what McCoy should have done. The Supreme Court , the state says

The high court agreed in October to hear the case.

McCoy's new lawyers say the concept of attorneys going against their client's wishes by admitting guilt is rare, but less so in Louisiana, where courts have accepted it. English said after the trial that he'd relied on a 2002 state court ruling on a similar case, from adjacent Caddo Parish, that supported the practice.

"This is really a Louisiana rule that grew out of Caddo Parish," Bourke said.

The Louisiana Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (LACDL) complained in a brief supporting McCoy that the local courts had turned the right to assistance of counsel "into the state's cudgel." The LACDL said that "an uncomfortable number of death sentences in Louisiana are the result of defendants representing themselves or defendants expressly objecting to their lawyers' concessions of guilt."

Related: Cash Bail, a Centerpiece of the Justice System, Is Facing Its Undoing

McCoy's ex-wife, Yolanda Colston, did not respond to requests for comment.

English, who left his full-time law practice to work in New York real estate development, declined in a recent interview to talk about specifics of the case. But he said he generally did not regret the way he represented clients, saying he did his best to advocate their best interests.

"A lawyer uses whatever strategies are available to them that are ethical and what the law permits him to do," English said.

Eleven states filed a joint brief in support of Louisiana, saying the case "presents a textbook example of a reasonable strategic concession."

But many lawyers say English served McCoy poorly. Among the groups who have filed briefs in support of McCoy are the the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, the American Bar Association, several prominent law professors and Yale Law School's Ethics Bureau.

"Mr. English acted in clear violation of his ethical obligations as a lawyer as well as Mr. McCoy's constitutional rights," the professors and Ethics Bureau said in a joint brief.

Peter Joy, a law professor at Washington University in St. Louis, agreed.

"If the strategy doesn't work, it's the client who is held responsible," Joy told NBC News. "The lawyer goes home. The client goes to prison or death row."

Image: Robert Mccoy, left, and his lawyer Larry English, right.Robert Mccoy, left, and his lawyer Larry English, right. © Provided by NBCU News Group, a division of NBCUniversal Media LLC Image: Robert Mccoy, left, and his lawyer Larry English, right.Robert Mccoy, left, and his lawyer Larry English, right.

Pregnant Khloé Kardashian loves the name Chi, still can't decide on own baby name .
Pregnant Khloé Kardashian loves the name Chi, still can't decide on own baby nameKhloé, 33, tweeted out to her almost 116 million followers on Friday at mega-Kylie Jenner fan Johnny Cyrus, "I can barely decide what I want to eat.

Source: http://us.pressfrom.com/news/us/-112396-can-a-lawyer-defy-his-client-and-say-hes-guilty-scotus-to-decide/

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!